When boardroom confidence exceeds cockpit competence.
My last post generated nearly a quarter of a million impressions. More interestingly, it prompted an extraordinary number of messages from people with remarkably similar experiences. Founders pushed out of businesses they created, promising companies wrecked by boardroom egos, greed, incompetence or some combination of all three. Years of work, millions in investment and perfectly good businesses disappearing down the drain. It’s clearly something of an epidemic.
There’s an analogy I’ve used for years to describe one particular form of this madness.
Imagine half a dozen frequent flyers sitting in business class somewhere over the Atlantic. Between them, they’ve accumulated millions of air miles, flown on every conceivable aircraft and know the difference between an Airbus and a Boeing. One of them even owns shares in an airline.
Eventually, one has a revelation. “We’ve probably spent more time on aeroplanes than the pilot. Why are we paying him to fly this thing?”
The others agree. It’s an excellent point. They summon the pilot, explain that the aircraft needs fresh leadership and inform him that, while his contribution to getting it off the ground is appreciated, it’s time for someone with more strategic experience to take over.
Naturally, they appoint a chairman. A consultant is brought in to review the flight plan. Someone suggests that the aircraft could fly faster if they switched off a few unnecessary systems. Another points out that the pilot has been consuming a disproportionate share of the cockpit’s resources. The pilot, meanwhile, is escorted back to economy.
For a while, everything seems to be going rather well. The aircraft is still flying, the new management team congratulates itself on a successful transition and the chairman announces that the business is now positioned for its next phase of growth.
Then they encounter some turbulence and discover that none of them knows how to fly the bloody thing.
The problem, of course, is that the aircraft is full of people who trusted someone to get them safely to their destination.
I’ve seen this happen in business more times than I care to remember. People who have sat on boards, invested in companies or managed established organisations become convinced that these experiences qualify them to build and run entrepreneurial businesses. Sometimes they do. Quite often, they don’t.
Building something from nothing is a very different discipline from supervising something that already exists. It requires judgement developed through years of making decisions without sufficient information, solving problems nobody has encountered before and persuading customers to buy things they didn’t know they needed. Those skills are remarkably easy to dismiss when you’ve never had to acquire them.
Of course, founders aren’t infallible. Some are terrible managers, some become obstacles to growth and sometimes the right decision really is to replace the pilot. But you might want to make sure the replacement can actually fly.
What has surprised me about the response to my previous post is not that this happens, but how frequently it seems to happen, and how often the consequences extend far beyond the founder. Employees lose careers, investors lose money, customers lose suppliers, technologies disappear and businesses that might have become something genuinely valuable are reduced to expensive cautionary tales.
All because a few people mistook sitting in business class for knowing how to fly an aeroplane.
I’d be interested in hearing more of these stories, because I suspect there are an awful lot of abandoned aircraft out there, and rather too many frequent flyers still looking for their next cockpit.
